Yes, the five governors got their answers. In identical letters dated November 12, 2026, the IRS's acting chief counsel told Govs. Healey, Newsom, Lamont, Whitmer and Sherrill that a state may require SGOs to protect student data, that a state reviews a multistate SGO through the §25F account kept for that state, and that no federal money is available for state oversight. The 2027 election deadline is January 1.
The IRS has answered the five governors. In a four-page letter dated November 12, 2026, Kevin Salinger, signing as the IRS's acting chief counsel, replied point by point to the October 22 letter in which Maura Healey of Massachusetts, Gavin Newsom of California, Ned Lamont of Connecticut, Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan and Mikie Sherrill of New Jersey asked for written answers before deciding on 2027. The copy addressed to Healey says an identical letter went to each of the other four. It became public this week when AFT Massachusetts posted a copy with a statement, New Bedford Guide reported on November 17. The letter makes no new rules. It explains how the IRS reads the temporary and proposed regulations published October 2, and it settles several points our November 10 review of the governors' questions found open: a state may require SGOs to protect student data, a state reviewing a multistate SGO looks at the §25F account kept for that state, and there is no federal money for state oversight. The deadline for a state's 2027 advance election, IRS Form 15714, is still January 1, 2027.
Student data: yes. The governors' first question was whether a state can require SGOs to keep systems that protect student data. The letter's answer: such a requirement “would seem consistent with the State administrative requirements allowed under § 1.25F-5T(e).” That section of the temporary regulations, which take effect without a comment period and apply from September 1, 2026, requires every participating state to hold SGOs to its general rules for charities, including what it takes to do business and solicit donations in the state, and to impose application, documentation and financial-reporting requirements reasonably tailored to the state's certifications and to catching fraud, such as two awards for the same expense. The limit is the one the rules already set, and the letter repeats it: a state may not make SGOs operate more restrictively than §25F(c)(5), “such as by limiting the type of school that scholarship recipients may attend or the types of qualified elementary or secondary education expenses for which scholarship funds may be used.” On November 10 we found the rules silent on student data. The IRS's reading puts a data-protection requirement on the permitted side of that line.
Multistate SGOs: each state reviews its own account. For every organization on its list, a state certifies that the organization is located in the state, keeps its §25F contributions separate, meets §25F(d)'s operating rules, and that the state has reviewed its audit and annual certifications (temp. § 1.25F-5T(d)(3)). For a multistate SGO, the letter says, the review of operating rules “would generally focus on the section 25F segregated account that the SGO maintains for that State,” and a state “would not need to review operational compliance in the section 25F segregated account held for any other State.” One rule reaches across accounts. Self-dealing, which §25F(d)(2) bars, can happen in one account or at the organization level, and “if the violation occurred at the organization level, the SGO would be disqualified in all States.” A state may also rely on the proposed definition of “located in a State” (prop. § 1.25F-1(b)(10)), meaning authorized to do business there and in compliance with its charity laws, to treat a multistate SGO as located in the state “even if the SGO is headquartered in another State.” For a national SGO applying in several states, that means each state checks the account kept for its own students.
What states get to see. Asked what information the IRS will give states so they can watch for fraud, the letter points to what SGOs must send states themselves. Each SGO certifies and reports to the IRS every year (prop. § 1.25F-4(d)), as part of its Form 990 or, if it doesn't file one, separately, and it “must concurrently provide the required information directly to each State” that lists it. Each SGO also commissions an annual financial and programmatic audit by a qualified independent third party and gives the results to every state that listed it (prop. § 1.25F-4(e)). The state, for its part, certifies that its own procedures, including how it assesses and responds to audit results, let it make its own determination about each SGO (temp. § 1.25F-5T(d)(6)), and it may ask an SGO for more documentation. The letter doesn't describe any data the IRS itself will pass along. To the governors' separate question about anti-fraud rules beyond the federal minimum, it answers that these two responses “describe the scope of permissible State requirements.”
Enforcement: states first, the IRS behind them. “States have primary responsibility for ensuring that SGOs comply with section 25F,” the letter says, and they must remove an SGO that breaks the rules (temp. § 1.25F-5T(d)(7)). The IRS can also remove an SGO from its list on its own ((d)(8)). And if the IRS finds “a pattern of irregularities or noncompliance” in how a state runs its review, it may require the state to change its procedures ((e)(3)), which the letter calls “an additional safeguard for effective State oversight of SGOs.”
The expense list and the tutoring safe harbor are still coming. On which tutoring, special-needs services, transportation, technology, after-school and summer programs qualify, the letter says guidance under §530 “is forthcoming” and that Treasury and the IRS “have received numerous stakeholder comments on these issues and are considering them as we develop that guidance.” It gives no date. The same day, Salinger told an audience in Washington that the IRS still aims to finish that guidance by the end of the year and will read the list as broadly as the statute allows (what he said). The governors also asked what the standards in the proposed low-income-area tutoring safe harbor mean: who counts as a qualified tutor, who can diagnose need, and what quality, duration and frequency are enough. The answer: “We will take them into consideration in developing the final rules.” Until then those terms stay undefined, and the safe harbor stays optional. An SGO can fund tutoring for a public school student by checking household income the ordinary way (how the safe harbor works).
Reaching the students with the most need. The governors asked what a state can do to steer scholarships toward low-income students, students with disabilities and students at high-poverty public schools without imposing requirements the rules bar. The letter's answer is outreach. Treasury and the IRS “encourage participating SGOs to highlight the particular mission and purpose of their charitable organizations to potential contributors,” and “schools and communities may also highlight partnerships with their preferred SGOs and scholarship opportunities for eligible students, consistent with other applicable laws and regulations.” States “may not impose discriminatory barriers beyond the statutory requirements of section 25F.” Public school districts are already taking that route, from Grand Island's own SGO in Nebraska to the Georgia districts working with the Georgia Foundation for Public Education. On collecting and publishing data about recipients' income, geography, schools or disabilities, the letter says the rules require only certain aggregated reporting, and that voluntary data gathering by a state or among SGOs “likely involves legal issues and requirements outside tax law.”
No federal money for state oversight. “At this time, Congress has neither authorized nor appropriated funds directly related to implementing the State policies and procedures required by the temporary and proposed rules,” the letter says. The rules do put part of the review work on SGOs rather than states: each SGO pays for its own annual audit and sends it to the state, and a new SGO can be reviewed on its governing documents and written policies until it has a reporting history (temp. § 1.25F-5T(d)(4)).
What happens next. The answers leave the five governors about six weeks. A state that wants its students in for 2027 files Form 15714 by January 1, 2027, then sends its SGO list to the IRS by February 15 (the full calendar). Healey's administration has said it is reviewing the regulations and hasn't announced a decision; AFT Massachusetts, which posted the letter, is urging her to stay out. Connecticut's next term begins January 6, so the 2027 decision there is Lamont's. Newsom leaves office in January, and Michigan's advance election is due the day Jocelyn Benson takes office. New York's Kathy Hochul, who said in May that she'd join only if public school students could benefit, read the same October rules, said yes on October 9 and opened New York's SGO application on November 16. The IRS's participating list showed 31 states as of November 13 (where every state stands).
For donors and organizations in these five states. Residents of California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Michigan and New Jersey can claim the credit in 2027 whatever their governor decides: up to $1,700 per taxpayer, or $3,400 on a joint return when each spouse gives under the proposed rules, by giving to an SGO in a participating state. The governor's decision controls whether students who live in the state can receive §25F scholarships (how an opt-out moves the money out of state). A school foundation or nonprofit that wants to serve these students can start forming now; our free SGO builder walks through each step, and each state's page tracks the decision: California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Michigan and New Jersey.
Sources
- IRS Office of Chief Counsel: letter from Kevin Salinger, Acting Chief Counsel, to Gov. Maura T. Healey (Nov. 12, 2026; identical letters to Govs. Newsom, Lamont, Whitmer and Sherrill), copy posted by AFT Massachusetts
- AFT Massachusetts: statement from President Jessica Tang on the Treasury letter
- New Bedford Guide: AFT Massachusetts urges Gov. Healey to opt out, citing the IRS reply (Nov. 17, 2026)
- Letter from Govs. Healey, Newsom, Lamont, Whitmer and Sherrill to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (Oct. 22, 2026), PDF posted by Education Week
- Federal Register, Oct. 2, 2026: Federal Scholarship Tax Credit, temporary regulations (T.D. 10057), § 1.25F-5T
- Federal Register, Oct. 2, 2026: Federal Scholarship Tax Credit, proposed regulations (REG-117199-25), §§ 1.25F-1 and 1.25F-4

